1 de junio de 2009

El Caso Boyero-Almodóvar. PARTE I

Criticastro: “el que sin apoyo, ni fundamento ni doctrina, censura y satiriza las obras de ingenio” (RAE)

Últimamente se ha puesto en duda la calidad informativa cultural del periódico El País por su cobertura del Festival de Cannes. Muchos lectores escribieron cartas al director quejándose de la misma, pero fue Pedro Almodóvar quién hizo que se desatara la polémica. En su Crónica Negra del Festival de Cannes critica el tratamiento que ha recibido su película por parte de Boyero, la decisión de El País (en concreto de Borja Hermoso, director de la sección cultural) de elegirlo como enviado especial del festival y el excesivo cariz opinativo de la cobertura. Un extenso documento que no tiene desperdicio y que parece desahogar sentimientos que vienen de lejos. El escrito provocó la respuesta de la redacción de cultura de El País, que se volcó a apoyar a su compañero, aunque su veracidad queda en entredicho, como bien dice Almodóvar, por ser Borja Hermoso el cabecilla de la redacción. Así mismo, El País devolvió a la Defensora del Lector las numerosas cartas recibidas en contra de la forma de hacer de Boyero, que esta ha desempolvado y nos muestra ahora (no antes).

----------------------------------------

Carlos Boyero, esa figura controvertida.

Este personaje siempre me pareció fuera de lugar. En el fondo, me gustaba por no tener pelos en la lengua, por no cortarse un pelo, por no seguir línea editorial alguna y por decir y escribir lo que se le antojaba. Libre. Libre de hacer lo que le de la santa gana y recibir un sueldito mensual por ello.

La cosa se complica cuando los lectores de un medio que se considera medianamente serio, empiezan a echar en falta una crítica cinematográfica coherente y de calidad. Boyero no es un crítico sino un opinador nato, un arrojador de subjetividades y un intransigente. Suelo leer sus artículos en El País y comprendí que no realizaba bien su trabajo cuando contó que se salió de la sala en un festival con la película a medias, y luego tuvo la indecencia de criticarla en el periódico. Le pagan por ver películas, no se le pide otra cosa que aguantar las dos horas de proyección. Y si esto no lo hace, ¿qué lo distingue de cualquiera de nosotros? Nosotros como simples mortales independientes, tenemos el privilegio de elegir las películas que nos gustan, dormirnos en el cine si nos apetece y salirnos de la sala cuando se nos antoje y además, podemos opinar lo que nos parezca.
Boyero es un profesional de la información (aunque sea eso lo que ahora está puesto en duda), y como tal debería, en primer lugar saber y delimitar su parcela periodística y el género al que se adscribe (por favor, eso se aprende en primero de carrera), y en segundo lugar, cumplir con sus obligaciones.

Siempre me pareció que El País no gestionaba bien las cartas al director, siempre laudatorias, pero bien es cierto que sabe hacer buen uso de las polémicas interesantes. La oleada de críticas a Boyero y al propio El País por su gestión del festival de Cannes han debido ser tales que el periódico ha decidido reflexionar y ya de paso dar la sensación de que escucha a sus lectores.

24 comentarios:

Guybrush dijo...

Parte I, y las que quedan: Trueba, De la Iglesia y otras 84 firmas cargan contra El País por un artículo sobre cineSiembra vientos...

Ana-Cronista dijo...

Si no recuerdo mal, el verano pasado varios directores atacaron a Boyero en otro comunicado.

A mí no me parece mal; el periódico es libre de publicar lo que quiera. Esta bien que se cree polémica. Esto es feedback y lo demás son tonterias!

Piloyo dijo...

Me ha gustado tu artículo; he leido los enlaces que pones a las distintas "partes" de este conflicto y me parece que aquí hay mucha tela que cortar. Almodovar está realmente dolido y no me extraña. Pero nosotros, sus lectores también debemos estar indignados, pues al fín y al cabo somos los que pagamos y deberíamos obtener a cambio una información más seria en todos los campos; ni tan subjetiva, ni tan partidista, y por supuesto más abierta a las críticas (lo de las cartas al director y lo de la defensora ¿del lector? canta demasiado. No creo, como dices al final, que haga buen uso de las polémicas, al revés, intenta solaparlas y cuando se le van de las manos, las corta. Todo este asunto me hace añorar mejores épocas de El País...
un saludo

Ana-Cronista dijo...

Piloyo, gracias por tu comentario.
No creo que El País haya cortado la polémica. Sí, que haya intentado solaparla y cuando se le ha ido de las manos ha querido explotarla.

Anónimo dijo...

Sinceramente nunca tuve mucha simpatía por Boyero, por todo lo que has dicho. Cuando empecé a interesarme un poco por el cine siempre me topaba con alguno de sus "escupitajos" criticos, y siempre sobraban las justificaciones.

Cuando un crítico, del medio que fuere, asumía el papel de destructor (o adulador) en vez del de evaluador, pierde toda credibilidad. Pero cuando no contento con esto entra en polémicas, contamina su medio y aquello que un principio le apasiona. Una pena.

Anónimo dijo...

Heyas im new[url=http://www.afrozmeet.com/chad8hjan9].[/url]

Anónimo dijo...

Hello,
I have developed a new clean web 2.0 wordpress theme.

Has 2 colours silver and blue, has custom header(colour or image).
I am curently working on it, so if you have suggestions let me know.

You can view live demo and download from here www.getbelle.com
If you found bug reports or you have suggestions pm me.
Wish you a happing using.

many thanks to [url=http://www.usainstantpayday.com/]USAInstantPayDay.com[/url] for paying the hosting and developement of the theme

DwelveVep

Anónimo dijo...

hello


just signed up and wanted to say hello while I read through the posts


hopefully this is just what im looking for looks like i have a lot to read.

Anónimo dijo...

if you guys exigency to jail [url=http://www.generic4you.com]viagra[/url] online you can do it at www.generic4you.com, the most trusted viagra pharmaceutics with a depiction generic drugs.
you can conceive of up with drugs like [url=http://www.generic4you.com/Sildenafil_Citrate_Viagra-p2.html]viagra[/url], [url=http://www.generic4you.com/Tadalafil-p1.html]cialis[/url], [url=http://www.generic4you.com/VardenafilLevitra-p3.html]levitra[/url] and more at www.rxpillsmd.net, the chief [url=http://www.rxpillsmd.net]viagra[/url] originator on the web. well another great [url=http://www.i-buy-viagra.com]viagra[/url] pharmacy you can find at www.i-buy-viagra.com

Anónimo dijo...

Hi folks,

What online mags do you read and would recommend?

For all you punk folks out there I recommend The Enough Fanzine. It is one of the first emo fanzines on the web.

They have throusands of reviews from the most underground bands all over the world. Check them out online: [url=http://www.enoughfanzine.com]Enough Fanzine[/url]. Best of it all, they are 100% non-profit and just helping the scene!

Looking forward to your recommendations.

Cheers!

Anónimo dijo...

How does one define a Utopian world and Utopian experiences? Well, you get to witness, enjoy and take bliss of the utopian universe here. Imagine the youthful escort walking hand in hand with you at your command. You can have her with you for a splashy massage, a fragrant shower or even for physical entertainment.

Hiring escort professional is same as hiring any other kind of professional, you have to pay for services, it does not matter you are professional or not.
[url=http://bijouescorts.com]Escorts[/url]
We know that one of the many frequent factors why men elect to spend time with New York escorts happens because of being lonely. It?s true that not each gentleman has the time or even the courage to walk up to a beautiful young lady and inquire the girl for a date. It has also been seen that there are several gents living alone in the planet without the enterprise of a woman friend or a accomplice. If any of this is the case with you, you probably crave for the warmth of a woman?s warm arms and the nice fragrance of her body. By hiring New York escorts, you will never have to fear rejection again. You will never have to spend a sleepless night asking yourself what exactly that lady?s answer might be.

A lot of researches have been made to overcome this problem. But the concept of having Sex to reduce stress and anxiety gained a lot of momentum in the western countries.

Escorts have the fairest of the bodies, while the tanned escorts are available in plenty if desired.

Anónimo dijo...

Hello man!

It is my first time here. I just wanted to say hi!

Anónimo dijo...

"We should have played more like a team instead of playing like a group of individuals. In the second half, we didn't play as we should. They started to attack when they saw that we weren't pressing we had before halftime. That was the time to be a team. Now, we can only think about La Liga, which is all we have left." [url=http://www.pulsebet.com]real madrid website[/url] Real Madrid maintains their fight for the title of the Spanish League after beating Real Zaragoza in an anguishing match, 2-1 this past Saturday. Real Zaragoza, which played the second half with ten players due to the expulsion of the Italian midfielder, Matteo Contini, were close to making a draw. However, a great goal from Kaka at minute 82 gave the Meringues the victory and moved them closer to Barcelona in the top spot by one point. Barcelona also took a victory after beating Xerez 3-1, leading with 87 points.

Higuain, recently recovered from his injury, exhibited his great talent as always and played for several minutes in the game. In the final minutes of the match, the player took a last opportunity at minute 90 and sealed his team’s victory with a third goal, his 12th of the season. The point puts Higuain three goals ahead of Cristiano Ronaldo, who was serving the second of his two-match outlaw. With this last play, Real Madrid ended the game with a final scoring of 3-0. [url=http://www.pulsebet.com]ronaldo[/url] Barcelona had other opportunities and some penalty appeals, but in the end the game finished 4-1 with a victory for Barca.

Anónimo dijo...

Another issue that you must stay on top of is price fluctuations from the bookmaker. The prices for placing bets do not just change with different bookies but even with the same. You cannot take it for granted that the prices that are quoted in print like the Racing Post will be valid at the time of the event. With sports betting things can change very rapidly so be sure that the price will be honored before placing your bet otherwise this can seriously affect the outcome of your arbitrage sports betting.
bet football | bet online sport betting
The best sports betting odds are in actuality just numbers, they may be an ever changing set of numbers but just numbers nonetheless. There are many different factors involved in the computation of not the least of which is the number of bettors placing bets on one team. If a bookie sees this happening he will give the team that is dentified as the loser more points and take points from the team deemed the winning team.
[url=http://www.pulsebet.com]football bet[/url]
For quite some time the United States House of Representatives has been trying to pass a bill that will make it much more difficult for people to get away with breaking the online gambling laws. Not to mention stricter penalties for those who are caught.

If you are employing neither of those two elements, then the risk you run of eventually losing your entire Base Bank is 99.99%. On the other hand, employing only a good Selection System would not only reduce your risk closer to just 10% maximum, you would also have up to a 10% chance of making money. This would mean that the Bookies would suddenly be faced with a 10% possibility of losing to you long-term, rather than a 99.99% certainty of taking your money from you. Throw in a proper Staking Plan on top of that, and you will have increased your chances of winning to as high as 20%.

Anónimo dijo...

4.) At the same time, do not become very greedy and play with only as many cards as you can play with. You need to watch and mark the winning numbers in each card and there is a time gap of only ten seconds between card draws. Hence, if you are unable to manage many cards, it is a waste. You have to complete winning combination and call 'bingo' before other players to claim your prize.
[url=http://www.bingokisses.com]new bingo[/url] play bingo If the second called number is say N36, probabilities of the next number not ending in 2 or 6 is more. The first six called numbers could have different digit endings. Thereafter, there could be pairing of one or more of such ending digits.
[url=http://www.bingokisses.com]bingos[/url]
If you do not know anyone who uses the gaming sites or you want some additional reinforcement your first port of call should be an online bingo community. By reading reviews by other people who use the Bingo sites, you will be able to get a feel for the different sites that exist and make a more qualified decision about which one you would like to use. The knowledge concerning different sites and what other users consider important about them is an invaluable tool for the new online Bingo player. Whether it is for fun or for money, there needs to be an element of integrity within the site and a potential for the player to win the game. The knowledge of other users concerning specific sites will tell the new online Bingo player whether the site is for real or is just masquerading in order to harvest the players email addresses in order to bombard them with spam, or worse con them out of their hard earned cash. This can all be avoided with research and trying before you buy, as mentioned earlier the best places to scope out bingo sites is by using a review site or Bingo members forum.
bingo online
Bingo is a beautiful game of luck, which involves patience, rapid coordination between hearing and searching out the numbers and lots of fun. As with all gambling bingo is totally addictive and you should be careful of its grip on you!

Anónimo dijo...

new guys! survey the latest free [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com]casino[/url] games like roulette and slots !research way out the all uncharted redeem [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com]online casino[/url] games at the all current www.casinolasvegass.com, the most trusted [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com]online casinos[/url] on the cobweb! exhume our [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/download.html]free casino software download[/url] and gain a victory in money.
you can also discontinuation other [url=http://sites.google.com/site/onlinecasinogames2010/]online casinos bonus[/url] . check out this new [url=http://www.place-a-bet.net/]online casino[/url].

Anónimo dijo...

Predilection casinos? examine this advanced [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]free casino[/url] games. director and postpone online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also into our untrained [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] manage at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and draw true fabulously distant !
another trendy [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino[/url] spiele plot is www.ttittancasino.com , because german gamblers, submit c be communicated past well-wishing online casino bonus.

Anónimo dijo...

Wassup

I wanted to share with you a great site I just came across teaching [url=http://www.kravmagabootcamp.com][b]Krav Maga[/b][/url] Online If you guys have seen the Tv Show called Fight Quest you would have seen their chief instructor Ran Nakash there featured on their [url=http://www.kravmagabootcamp.com][b]Krav Maga[/b][/url] episode. Anyways, let me know what you think. Is training via the internet something you would do?


regards

Joe

Anónimo dijo...

kpquwcx xge eyoen bikini models

wmgyj!

tqqrh qvhriy aww hand job clips

Anónimo dijo...

fyyx peodp [URL=http://www.katesxxx.com]milfs[/URL] unjuon a mx x daq

Anónimo dijo...

[url=http://casodex-bicalutamide.webs.com/]Bicalutamide tablets
[/url] Bicalutamide 50 mg online
cheannach Casodex
order Casodex online

Anónimo dijo...

Believe it or not, but [url=http://nhommuagiatot.com/thoi-trang.html]Thoi trang nam[/url] has impacted the lives of untold numbers of people. We see so many cases in our every day lives, and it can serve as an significant reminder. What is curious about this is the amount of material that is generally unknown to people.

Generally speaking, folks have observed so much or directly experienced what is possible. Not only that, but it is completely natural and normal to want to find what you are looking for. That is why we want to provide you with some relevant tips about this topic, and with any luck , they will help you in the long term.

The general difficulties of men's and women's style

Both men and women could have the pressures of keeping their wardrobe up-to-date and in season, yet men's fashion frequently seems a lot easier. Of program, for both sexes, outfits and style choices can be quite as elaborate, and there are numerous'stylish'things that could easily become fashion faux pas - who are able to say they often see people walking on in 70s flames? On the other hand, men's style has a few choice items which can exist forever - which man is planning to keep an eye out of place with a good-quality, tailored suit, for instance? Choose basic cuts, colours and materials and you'll never seem out-of-place.

Why common men's style is eternal

The common man's suit has hardly changed for over a hundred years. True, there are many varieties for different situations, however they are all common in their search for a clever, sharp search for the person. The neat thing about basic style for men is that it's effortlessly stylish effortlessly neat. A well-groomed lady will almost always appear his sharpest in a well-tailored suit, and this can be a testament to the design of such apparel. A match will undoubtedly be used to work in many jobs due to the professional search it provides to the person, instilling a feeling of respect and confidence. Equally a match will be used to several social functions, like a tuxedo to a black-tie event. This extraordinary flexibility that enables suits to be worn in virtually all situations is what gives it its amazing advantage and a lasting invest men's fashion.

Contemporary developments in traditional men's style

Whilst classic men's styles will never be replaced, it's interesting to observe that shifts in men's fashion trends have brought certain common garments back into fashion. The reputation of vintage clothing, particularly, has had back a wide-variety of basic models into men's closets, such as that of the dandy man. 'Dandy'is a term used to make reference to men who dress yourself in a classic yet luxurious way, placing value on appearance and acting in a refined approach. This development for almost'over-the-top'classic fashion for men is apparent from events including the'Tweed Run', where men and girls of all ages dress yourself in obviously Victorian-style attire and decide to try the streets on vintage bikes - with many of the men sporting flawless mustaches! This is just one of several types of data presenting the resurgence of such designs. Additionally, there are numerous blogs online which focus on gentlemanly type - such as'The Dandy Project'and'Dandyism'- as well as whole internet sites such as'The Art of Manliness'specialized in providing articles on traditional men's fashion and grooming.

In summary, although certain facets of basic men's fashion may be brought back as new developments, the essential garments which they are based on will never fall out of fashion.

"All it will take are a few basic clothes. And there is one secret - the easier the better." - Cary Grant

StyleGun is an online men's fashion shop with a complex twist.
Read More: [url=http://lightacademy.ro/blogs/40598/133608/thoi-trang-nam-va-trao-luu-2012]thoi trang nam body[/url]

Anónimo dijo...

Jq8Dq5
[url=http://gutianle.tumblr.com/13030802]zapatos isabel marant[/url]
[url=http://isabelsneakerus.evenweb.com/sections/sac-longchamps-en-ligne]portefeuille longchamp[/url]
[url=http://shoeshopsale.dinstudio.com/0/6/isabel-marant-gym-shoes]isabel marant tennis shoes[/url]

Cl9Nz5Me9Hg5
http://isabellemaranti.mywapblog.com/cheap-isabel-marant-sneakers-online-sale.xhtml
http://isabelsneakerus.evenweb.com/sections/isabel-marant-divers-pour-votre
http://isableingok.webgarden.com/sections/isabel-marant-very-popular

Anónimo dijo...

http://biaxin-buy.webs.com/ clarithromycin online apotheke
http://sustiva-efavirenz.webs.com/ order Efavirenz 500 mg online
http://asacol-mesalamine.webs.com/ purchase pentasa
http://www.freewebs.com/pentasa-mesalamine/ canasta online